Buddhism and Heterodox Movements in Ancient India

In this part we learn Buddhism and Heterodox Movements in Ancient India in detailed.

Table of Contents

INTRODUCTION: Conceptual Framework

The 6th century BCE witnessed a remarkable intellectual and spiritual revolution in India, characterized by the emergence of heterodox (non-Vedic) movements that challenged Brahmanical orthodoxy. This period, often called the “Age of Great Thinkers”, produced Buddhism, Jainism, and other philosophical schools that fundamentally transformed Indian religious, social, and cultural landscape.

Heterodox Movements: Religious and philosophical schools that rejected Vedic authority, ritualism, and Brahmanical supremacy.

UPSC Significance: Understanding these movements is crucial for:

Religious evolution in India
Social reform movements (anti-caste, anti-ritual)
Philosophical traditions (logic, ethics, metaphysics)
Cultural continuity (influence on later Indian thought)
Contemporary relevance (Ahimsa, Middle Path, social equality)
India’s soft power (Buddhism’s global spread)

I. HISTORICAL CONTEXT: WHY HETERODOX MOVEMENTS AROSE

A. Socio-Economic Factors (6th Century BCE)

1. Second Urbanization:

Decline of Painted Grey Ware (PGW) culture → Rise of Northern Black Polished Ware (NBP)
New urban centers: Rajagriha, Vaishali, Kausambi, Taxila, Ujjain, Varanasi
Trade and commerce expansion
Artisan and merchant classes (Vaishyas) gaining economic power but lacking social status
Demand for new ideology: Mercantile class wanted religion emphasizing ethics, not expensive rituals

2. Iron Technology:

Iron ploughshare → Agricultural surplus
Gangetic plains brought under cultivation
Economic prosperity but social tensions

3. Rise of Mahajanapadas:

16 territorial states (monarchies and republics)
Political consolidation
Magadha’s rise
Kshatriya rulers (often from republican states) challenging Brahmanical supremacy

B. Religious Factors

1. Brahmanical Excesses:

Complex, expensive rituals (Yajnas) requiring Brahmin intermediaries
Sacrificial system: Animal sacrifices (especially horse sacrifice – Ashvamedha)
Sanskrit monopoly: Vedas in Sanskrit (inaccessible to masses)
Ritualism over ethics: Focus on ceremonies, not moral conduct
Brahmin privileges: Social and economic dominance

2. Rigidity of Varna System:

Birth-based hierarchy: Brahmins supreme, Shudras oppressed
Kshatriyas resented: Despite being warriors/rulers, placed below Brahmins
Vaishyas frustrated: Wealthy merchants but low social status
Shudras excluded: From religious practices, education

3. Status of Women:

Declining from Rigvedic period
Patriarchal practices strengthening
Exclusion from rituals, education

4. Philosophical Fatigue:

Upanishadic philosophy (Brahman, Atman) abstract, elite
Common people needed practical ethics, not metaphysics
Desire for personal salvation path without priestly mediation

C. Philosophical Factors

1. Upanishadic Transition:

Later Vedic period: Upanishads questioned ritualism
Shift from Karma-Kanda (rituals) to Jnana-Kanda (knowledge)
Prepared ground for heterodox movements
But remained within Vedic framework

2. Spirit of Inquiry:

Shramana tradition (wandering ascetics) already existed
Free thinkers, debaters
Skepticism, empiricism emerging
62 philosophical schools mentioned in Buddhist texts!

3. Search for Salvation:

Samsara (cycle of rebirth) and Karma concepts accepted
But dissatisfaction with Vedic methods of liberation
Desire for individual effort-based salvation, not birth-based privilege

D. Political Patronage

1. Kshatriya Support:

Many founders were Kshatriyas (Buddha, Mahavira)
Challenged Brahmin superiority
Republican states (Vajji, Malla) especially supportive

2. Royal Patronage:

Bimbisara (Magadha) – supported Buddha, Mahavira
Ajatashatru – continued support
Ashoka (later) – Buddhism’s greatest patron
Kings saw heterodox movements as:
- Ideological alternative to Brahmin dominance
- Ethical governance philosophy
- Popular support base

UPSC Analytical Framework: Heterodox movements were NOT purely religious phenomena but socio-economic-political responses to changing times. They represented:

Economic classes (merchants) seeking social legitimacy
Political classes (Kshatriyas) challenging Brahmin supremacy
Oppressed castes (Shudras) seeking dignity
Women seeking spiritual access
Intellectuals seeking rational philosophy

II. BUDDHISM: THE LIFE AND TEACHINGS OF GAUTAMA BUDDHA

A. The Historical Buddha: Siddhartha to Enlightenment

1. Birth and Early Life:

Name: Siddhartha Gautama (Siddhārtha = “One who achieves his aim”) Clan: Shakya (hence Shakyamuni – “Sage of Shakyas”) Birth: ~563 BCE (traditional date; some scholars say 480 BCE) Place: Lumbini (modern Nepal, near Kapilavastu) Family:

Father: Shuddhodana (Shakya clan chief, often called “king” but likely oligarchic republic)
Mother: Mayadevi (died 7 days after birth)
Stepmother: Mahaprajapati Gautami (raised Siddhartha)
Wife: Yashodhara (married at 16)
Son: Rahula (born just before renunciation)

Childhood Prophecy:

Sage Asita predicted: Siddhartha would become either great king or great spiritual teacher
Shuddhodana wanted him to be king
Kept in luxury, shielded from suffering

2. The Four Sights (Catalysts for Renunciation):

Despite luxurious life in palace, Siddhartha ventured outside:

First Sight: Old Man (bent, wrinkled, feeble)

Realization: Aging is inevitable

Second Sight: Sick Man (diseased, suffering)

Realization: Disease strikes all

Third Sight: Corpse (funeral procession)

Realization: Death is certain

Fourth Sight: Wandering Ascetic (calm, serene despite having nothing)

Realization: Possible to find peace amidst suffering
Inspired to seek spiritual path

Significance: These sights revealed universal suffering (Dukkha) and possibility of transcendence

3. The Great Renunciation (Mahabhinishkramana):

Age: 29 years Event: Left palace at night

Said goodbye to sleeping wife and newborn son (without waking – poignant moment)
Rode horse (Kanthaka) with charioteer (Channa) to forest edge
Cut off hair with sword (symbol of renunciation)
Exchanged princely clothes for ascetic robes
Sent Channa back with horse

Why Renounce?:

Birth of son made him realize: “Another bond (Rahula = fetter) to Samsara”
Urgency to solve problem of suffering before old age/death
Dissatisfaction with sensual pleasures (realized impermanence)

UPSC Point: Great Renunciation shows Buddha’s extraordinary compassion (left family to find solution for ALL beings’ suffering, not just personal salvation)

4. The Quest (Six Years of Spiritual Seeking):

Phase 1: Study with Teachers (2 years):

First Teacher: Alara Kalama

Taught meditation (Samadhi)
Achieved “Sphere of Nothingness” (high meditative state)
But Siddhartha realized: Temporary peace, not permanent liberation
Left to find deeper truth

Second Teacher: Uddaka Ramaputta

Taught advanced meditation
Achieved “Sphere of Neither Perception nor Non-Perception” (highest meditative state)
Again, Siddhartha unsatisfied: No permanent solution to suffering
Decided to find own path

Phase 2: Extreme Asceticism (6 years):

Location: Uruvela forest (near Bodh Gaya), Bihar Companions: Five ascetics (Kondanna, Bhaddiya, Vappa, Mahanama, Assaji)

Practices:

Extreme fasting (one grain of rice per day, some say)
Body emaciated (ribs visible, skin blackened)
Breath control (painful pranayama)
Exposure to elements
Self-mortification

Realization:

Asceticism also extreme (just as palace luxury was)
Body weakened, mind couldn’t concentrate
Neither indulgence nor self-torture leads to liberation
Middle Way needed!

Critical Moment:

Fainted from weakness
Revived, decided to eat (accepted rice pudding from Sujata, village girl)
Five companions abandoned him (thought he’d given up)
Alone but determined

5. The Enlightenment (Bodhi):

Date: Full moon night of Vaishakha (April-May), ~528 BCE (or ~400 BCE) Place: Under Pipal tree (later called Bodhi Tree) at Bodh Gaya, Bihar Age: 35 years

The Night of Enlightenment (Three Watches):

First Watch (Evening):

Memory of past lives (Pubbenivasanussati-nana)
Saw his own previous births, deaths, rebirths
Understood continuity of existence

Second Watch (Midnight):

Divine Eye (Dibbacakkhu-nana)
Saw all beings dying and being reborn according to their karma
Understood law of karma and rebirth

Third Watch (Pre-dawn):

Understanding of Four Noble Truths
Destruction of all defilements (Asava-kkhaya-nana)
Realized cause of suffering and path to end it
Achieved Nirvana (complete liberation)

Mara’s Temptation (Buddhist tradition):

Mara (personification of evil, death, temptation) tried to prevent enlightenment
Sent armies (fear)
Sent daughters (desire)
Buddha touched earth (Bhumisparsha Mudra): “Earth is my witness”
Mara defeated
Symbolism: Overcoming inner demons (greed, hatred, delusion)

Moment of Enlightenment:

Dawn broke
Siddhartha became Buddha (“The Awakened One”)
Realized: “Birth is destroyed, holy life has been lived, what had to be done has been done, there is no more coming into any state of being”

What He Realized:

Four Noble Truths (Arya Satya)
Dependent Origination (Pratityasamutpada) – chain of causation
Middle Way (Madhyama Pratipad) – between extremes
Nature of reality: Impermanence (Anicca), Suffering (Dukkha), Non-self (Anatta)

Initial Hesitation:

Buddha thought: “This truth is too subtle, profound”
“People attached to pleasures won’t understand”
Considered not teaching (remaining in Nirvanic bliss)
Brahma Sahampati (divine being) requested him to teach: “Some will understand!”
Buddha’s compassion prevailed: Decided to teach

UPSC Significance: Enlightenment represents culmination of rational inquiry, meditation, and ethical living – not divine revelation or faith alone. Scientific, empirical approach to spiritual truth.

6. First Sermon (Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta):

Location: Deer Park (Sarnath) near Varanasi, UP Audience: Five former companions (now first five disciples) Content:

Four Noble Truths
Eightfold Path
Middle Way

“Setting in Motion the Wheel of Dharma” (Dharmachakra Pravartana)

Reaction:

Five ascetics became first Bhikkhus (monks)
First Sangha (monastic community) formed
Buddhism born

7. Teaching Ministry (45 Years):

Age: 35 to 80 years Area: Middle Gangetic plains (Bihar, UP, Nepal Terai) Cities frequented: Rajagriha, Vaishali, Shravasti, Kausambi, Varanasi

Method:

Wandering teacher (except rainy season – Vassavasa)
Begging for food (Bhiksha)
Teaching in Pali (vernacular, not Sanskrit!)
Adapting message to audience (farmers, kings, merchants, women)
Dialogues, debates (not sermons from authority)

Key Conversions:

Sariputta and Moggallana: Chief disciples (foremost in wisdom and psychic powers)
Ananda: Personal attendant, recorded teachings (excellent memory)
Mahakashyapa: Leader after Buddha (convened First Council)
Yashodhara and Mahaprajapati: Wife and stepmother became nuns
Rahula: Son became monk
Kings: Bimbisara (Magadha), Prasenajit (Kosala) – patrons
Merchants: Anathapindika (donated Jetavana monastery)

Major Monasteries:

Jetavana (Shravasti) – donated by Anathapindika
Bamboo Grove (Veluvana) (Rajagriha) – donated by Bimbisara
Mango Grove (Vaishali)

Challenges:

Devadatta (cousin) tried to kill him, split Sangha (failed)
Opposition from Brahmins (but some converted)
Exhausting teaching schedule

8. Parinirvana (Death):

Age: 80 years Date: ~483 BCE (or ~400 BCE) Place: Kushinagara (modern UP, near Nepal border)

Final Journey:

From Rajagriha to Kushinagara
Fell ill (possibly food poisoning from spoiled pork offered by Chunda, blacksmith)
Lay down between two Sal trees
Final words: “Vayadhamma sankhara, appamadena sampadetha”
- “All compounded things are subject to decay, strive with diligence (for liberation)”
Entered Parinirvana (final Nirvana, no rebirth)

Aftermath:

Body cremated
Relics distributed among 8 clans (stupas built over them)
Ashoka later redistributed relics (84,000 stupas tradition)
Mourned across kingdoms

Legacy:

Transformed from prince to “Light of Asia”
Founded religion followed by 500+ million today
Teachings preserved by oral tradition, later written (Tripitaka)

UPSC Perspective: Buddha’s life shows power of rational inquiry, compassion, and perseverance. Relevant for contemporary issues: Non-violence, middle path (avoiding extremes), empirical approach to truth, social equality.

B. Core Buddhist Teachings

1. THE FOUR NOBLE TRUTHS (Arya Satya)

The Foundation: Buddha’s diagnosis and prescription for human condition

Structure: Medical metaphor

Disease (suffering)
Diagnosis (cause)
Prognosis (cure possible)
Prescription (treatment)

FIRST NOBLE TRUTH: DUKKHA (Suffering/Unsatisfactoriness)

Statement: “Life is suffering” (Dukkha)

Clarification: Not pessimistic nihilism, but realistic assessment

Three Types of Dukkha:

Dukkha-dukkha (Suffering of suffering):
- Physical pain, mental anguish
- Birth, aging, sickness, death
- Separation from loved ones
- Association with disliked
- Not getting what one desires
Viparinama-dukkha (Suffering of change):
- Impermanence of pleasant experiences
- Even happiness is unsatisfactory because temporary
- Joy of youth → sorrow of aging
- Health → disease
- Wealth → poverty (can happen)
Sankhara-dukkha (Suffering of conditioned existence):
- Very existence is unsatisfactory
- Five aggregates (Skandhas) that constitute “self” are impermanent
- Clinging to impermanent aggregates causes suffering
- Most subtle form

UPSC Point: Dukkha often mistranslated as “suffering” – better: “unsatisfactoriness,” “dis-ease,” “stress”. Life has pleasures but they’re impermanent, conditional, ultimately unsatisfying. Buddha’s realism, not pessimism.

SECOND NOBLE TRUTH: SAMUDAYA (Origin/Cause of Suffering)

Statement: Suffering arises from Tanha (craving/thirst/desire)

Three Types of Tanha:

Kama-tanha (Craving for sensual pleasures):
- Desire for pleasant sights, sounds, smells, tastes, touches
- Sexual desire
- Craving for material objects
Bhava-tanha (Craving for existence/becoming):
- Desire to exist, become something
- Craving for life, immortality
- Desire for identity, status, power
- “I want to be…”
Vibhava-tanha (Craving for non-existence/annihilation):
- Desire to not exist (suicidal tendencies)
- Nihilistic craving
- “I don’t want to be…”
- Avoidance, escapism

Deeper Analysis: Dependent Origination (Pratityasamutpada):

Buddha explained suffering through 12-linked chain of causation:

Avijja (Ignorance) →
Sankhara (Volitional formations/karma) →
Vinnana (Consciousness) →
Nama-rupa (Name-and-form, mind-and-body) →
Salayatana (Six sense bases) →
Phassa (Contact) →
Vedana (Feeling/sensation) →
Tanha (Craving) →
Upadana (Clinging/attachment) →
Bhava (Becoming/existence) →
Jati (Birth) →
Jara-marana (Aging-and-death), sorrow, pain

Key Insight:

Ignorance (of true nature of reality) is root cause
Ignorance → Craving → Suffering
Not external circumstances but internal reactions cause suffering
Break chain at any link → suffering ends

UPSC Application: Second Truth shows suffering is self-created through craving born of ignorance. Implies: We have agency – can end suffering by changing ourselves, not blaming external factors. Relevant for personal responsibility, mental health.

THIRD NOBLE TRUTH: NIRODHA (Cessation of Suffering)

Statement: Suffering CAN end – Nirvana is possible

Nirvana (Nibbana in Pali):

Etymology: Nir (out) + vana (blowing) = “Blowing out” (of flame of craving)

Not:

❌ Annihilation (nihilism)
❌ Heaven (eternal bliss realm)
❌ Union with God
❌ Unconscious state
❌ Death

What it IS:

✅ Cessation of craving, hatred, delusion
✅ End of suffering while still alive
✅ Freedom from Samsara (cycle of rebirth)
✅ Unconditioned state (not dependent on causes)
✅ Perfect peace, wisdom, compassion

Two Aspects:

Sopadisesa-nibbana (Nirvana with residue):
- Achieved while alive
- Body remains (residue of past karma)
- No new karma created
- Live in perfect peace, wisdom
- Buddha after enlightenment (lived 45 more years in Nirvana state)
Anupadisesa-nibbana (Nirvana without residue):
- At death of enlightened being
- No rebirth (cycle broken)
- Parinirvana (final Nirvana)
- Complete cessation

Characteristics (Buddha’s Description):

“Unborn, unoriginated, uncreated, unformed”
“Highest happiness”
“End of suffering”
“Deathless”
Cannot be fully described (beyond concepts)
Must be experienced (like honey’s taste – must taste it!)

UPSC Point: Nirvana is empirically achievable, not faith-based promise of afterlife. This-worldly liberation, not other-worldly heaven. Testable through practice. Appeals to rational, scientific mindset.

FOURTH NOBLE TRUTH: MAGGA (Path to End Suffering)

Statement: There IS a path – Noble Eightfold Path (Arya Ashtangika Marga)

The Treatment Plan – will be detailed in next section

Why “Noble”?: Path walked by Aryas (noble ones, enlightened beings), leading to noble goal (Nirvana)

Summary of Four Noble Truths:

Truth	Aspect	Medical Analogy	Statement
Dukkha	Problem	Disease	Life involves suffering
Samudaya	Cause	Diagnosis	Craving (born of ignorance) causes suffering
Nirodha	Solution	Prognosis	Suffering CAN end (Nirvana possible)
Magga	Method	Prescription	Eightfold Path is the way

UPSC Analytical Framework:

Empirical, scientific approach: Observe problem, identify cause, propose solution, provide method
Practical, not theoretical: Buddha refused metaphysical speculation (“Does God exist?” “Is universe eternal?”), focused on ending suffering
Universal: Applies to all humans, regardless of caste, gender, nationality
Psychological: Focus on mind training, not external rituals
Optimistic: Problem has solution; humans can liberate themselves

2. THE NOBLE EIGHTFOLD PATH (Arya Ashtangika Marga)

The WAY to Liberation – Buddha’s practical program

Structure: Eight interconnected practices, grouped into Three Trainings (Trisiksha):

Prajna (Wisdom) – Right Understanding, Right Intention
Sila (Morality) – Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood
Samadhi (Meditation) – Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, Right Concentration

Not Sequential (1→2→3→…→8) but Simultaneous – develop together, mutually support

I. PRAJNA (Wisdom Group)

1. SAMMA DITTHI (Right View/Understanding):

Definition: Understanding reality as it is, not as we imagine

Core Understandings:

Four Noble Truths (foundation)
Three Characteristics of Existence:
1. Anicca (Impermanence): All conditioned things change
2. Dukkha (Unsatisfactoriness): Clinging to impermanent causes suffering
3. Anatta (Non-self): No permanent, unchanging self/soul
Karma and Rebirth: Actions have consequences, rebirth based on karma
Dependent Origination: Nothing exists independently, all interconnected

Wrong Views to Abandon:

Eternalism (soul/self is permanent)
Nihilism (nothing matters, no rebirth, no karma)
Materialism (only matter exists)
Determinism (fate controls everything)

Importance: Foundation of path – wrong view leads astray; right view guides

2. SAMMA SANKAPPA (Right Intention/Thought):

Definition: Cultivating wholesome mental attitudes

Three Aspects:

Nekkhamma (Renunciation): Intention to let go of attachments
- Not necessarily monasticism for all
- Inner detachment from sensual cravings
Abyapada (Good will/Non-ill-will): Intention of loving-kindness
- Wishing happiness for all beings
- Opposite of hatred, anger
Avihimsa (Non-harming): Intention of compassion
- Not hurting any living being
- Opposite of cruelty

Importance: Thought precedes action – purifying intentions purifies actions

II. SILA (Morality Group) – Ethical Conduct

Foundation: Ahimsa (Non-violence), Karuna (Compassion), Metta (Loving-kindness)

3. SAMMA VACA (Right Speech):

Definition: Speaking truthfully, beneficially, harmoniously

Four Abstentions:

Abstain from lying (Musavada): Speak truth
Abstain from divisive speech (Pisunavaca): Don’t create discord
Abstain from harsh speech (Pharusavaca): Speak gently, kindly
Abstain from idle chatter (Samphappalapa): Speak purposefully, meaningfully

Positive Practice:

Speak what is true AND beneficial
If true but not beneficial → silence better
If beneficial but not true → never speak (dishonest)
Best: True + Beneficial + Timely + Gentle

Test Before Speaking (Buddhist guideline):

Is it TRUE?
Is it KIND?
Is it NECESSARY?
Is it the RIGHT TIME?

4. SAMMA KAMMANTA (Right Action):

Definition: Ethical physical conduct

Five Precepts (Pancha Sila) – for laypeople:

Abstain from killing (Panatipata): No harming living beings
Abstain from stealing (Adinnadana): No taking what’s not given
Abstain from sexual misconduct (Kamesu micchacara): No adultery, rape, etc.
Abstain from lying (Musavada): Speak truth
Abstain from intoxicants (Suramerayamajja): No alcohol, drugs clouding mind

Ten Precepts (for monks, nuns):

Above 5, plus:

Abstain from eating after noon
Abstain from entertainment, adornment
Abstain from luxurious beds
Abstain from accepting gold/silver (money)
(Varies by tradition)

Positive Actions:

Dana (Generosity): Giving, charity
Metta (Loving-kindness): Cultivating goodwill
Karuna (Compassion): Helping suffering beings

5. SAMMA AJIVA (Right Livelihood):

Definition: Earning living ethically, harmlessly

Five Trades to Avoid:

Trading in weapons: Tools of killing
Trading in living beings: Slavery, prostitution, animal trade for slaughter
Trading in meat: Butchery (though eating meat debated – Buddha ate meat offered as alms)
Trading in intoxicants: Alcohol, drugs
Trading in poison: Harmful substances

Positive Livelihood:

Work that doesn’t harm others
Honest, fair dealings
Service-oriented professions encouraged

Modern UPSC Relevance:

Ethical business practices
Corporate social responsibility
Sustainable, non-exploitative economics
Work-life balance (not excessive attachment to career)

III. SAMADHI (Meditation Group) – Mental Discipline

6. SAMMA VAYAMA (Right Effort):

Definition: Persistent effort in mental cultivation

Four Types of Effort:

Effort to prevent unwholesome states not yet arisen:
- Guard sense doors
- Avoid tempting situations
- Mindfulness of triggers
Effort to abandon unwholesome states already arisen:
- Let go of anger, greed, delusion when they appear
- Don’t feed negative emotions
Effort to cultivate wholesome states not yet arisen:
- Develop loving-kindness, compassion, wisdom
- Practice meditation, study Dharma
Effort to maintain wholesome states already arisen:
- Sustain positive mental states
- Deepen meditation, wisdom

Balance: Not too tense (breaks), not too lax (no progress)

Middle Way in effort – like tuning string (Buddha’s simile to musician)

7. SAMMA SATI (Right Mindfulness):

Definition: Present-moment awareness, clear comprehension

Four Foundations of Mindfulness (Satipatthana):

Kayanupassana (Mindfulness of Body):
- Breathing: Anapanasati (watching breath in-out)
- Postures: Aware of sitting, standing, walking, lying
- Activities: Mindful eating, dressing, etc.
- Body parts: Contemplating hair, nails, teeth… (counteracts attachment)
- Elements: Body as earth, water, fire, air
- Death: Contemplating corpse in stages of decay (Maran

Death: Contemplating corpse in stages of decay (Maranasati) – impermanence

Vedananupassana (Mindfulness of Feelings/Sensations):
- Pleasant, unpleasant, neutral sensations
- Observe without reacting (key practice!)
- See arising and passing of feelings
- Breaks automatic reaction chain (feeling → craving → suffering)
Cittanupassana (Mindfulness of Mind/Mental States):
- Aware of mind with/without greed, hatred, delusion
- Concentrated or distracted
- Expansive or contracted
- Observing observer – meta-awareness
Dhammanupassana (Mindfulness of Mental Objects/Phenomena):
- Five Hindrances: Sensual desire, ill-will, sloth, restlessness, doubt
- Seven Factors of Enlightenment: Mindfulness, investigation, energy, joy, tranquility, concentration, equanimity
- Four Noble Truths: Direct contemplation

Modern Application: Vipassana meditation (insight meditation) based on Satipatthana

S.N. Goenka popularized globally
Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) in West
Clinical psychology applications

8. SAMMA SAMADHI (Right Concentration):

Definition: One-pointed, focused mind; deep meditative absorption

Four Jhanas (Meditative Absorptions):

First Jhana:

Directed thought (Vitakka), sustained thought (Vicara)
Joy (Piti), happiness (Sukha)
One-pointedness
Seclusion from sensual pleasures

Second Jhana:

Directed/sustained thought ceases
Internal confidence, unification of mind
Joy and happiness remain

Third Jhana:

Joy fades
Equanimity arises
Happiness continues
Mindfulness and clear comprehension

Fourth Jhana:

Happiness ceases
Pure equanimity and mindfulness
Neither pleasure nor pain
Profound peace

Beyond Jhanas: Formless Absorptions (Arupa Jhanas):

Sphere of Infinite Space
Sphere of Infinite Consciousness
Sphere of Nothingness
Sphere of Neither Perception nor Non-Perception

But: Even highest jhanas are not Nirvana – temporary states

Insight (Vipassana) needed along with Concentration (Samatha)
Concentration calms mind; Insight liberates

Samadhi’s Role:

Purifies mind
Develops psychic powers (Abhinna) – but not goal
Prepares for liberating insight

EIGHTFOLD PATH – Summary Table:

Factor	Pali Term	Training	Focus	Practical Application
1. Right View	Samma Ditthi	Prajna (Wisdom)	Understanding reality	Study Four Noble Truths
2. Right Intention	Samma Sankappa	Prajna (Wisdom)	Wholesome motivation	Cultivate renunciation, goodwill, compassion
3. Right Speech	Samma Vaca	Sila (Morality)	Ethical communication	Truth, harmony, gentleness, purpose
4. Right Action	Samma Kammanta	Sila (Morality)	Ethical conduct	Five/Ten Precepts
5. Right Livelihood	Samma Ajiva	Sila (Morality)	Ethical work	Harmless profession
6. Right Effort	Samma Vayama	Samadhi (Meditation)	Mental energy	Prevent/abandon unwholesome, cultivate/maintain wholesome
7. Right Mindfulness	Samma Sati	Samadhi (Meditation)	Present awareness	Four Foundations (body, feelings, mind, phenomena)
8. Right Concentration	Samma Samadhi	Samadhi (Meditation)	One-pointed focus	Four Jhanas, meditative absorption

UPSC Significance:

Practical, actionable path – not abstract philosophy
Holistic development: Wisdom, ethics, meditation together
Gradual training: Accessible to all, step-by-step
Empirically verifiable: Results testable through practice
Universal applicability: For monks and laypeople
Middle Way exemplified: Avoiding extremes in each factor
Relevant today: Mindfulness, ethical living, mental health

3. CONCEPT OF NIRVANA (Nibbana)

Already covered in Third Noble Truth, but deeper analysis:

Philosophical Questions:

Q: Does enlightened person exist after death? Buddha’s Answer: Unanswerable (Avyakata) – question wrongly framed

Why Unanswerable?:

Assumes permanent “person” exists (violates Anatta)
“Exist” and “not exist” are conceptual categories
Nirvana transcends concepts
Like asking: “Where does flame go when candle extinguished?”
- Doesn’t go anywhere – conditions for flame cease
- Similarly, conditions for rebirth (craving, ignorance) cease

Buddha’s Simile:

Ocean (Nirvana) is beyond measurement
Don’t ask: “How deep?” – immeasurable
Can only know by diving in (experiencing)

Two Truths Doctrine (Mahayana development):

Conventional Truth (Samvr̥ti-satya): Ordinary language, concepts (person, self, existence)
Ultimate Truth (Paramārtha-satya): Reality beyond concepts (Nirvana, Emptiness)
Nirvana can’t be captured in conventional language

Positive Descriptions (Buddha used):

“Island amidst flood”
“Refuge”
“Deathless”
“Peace”
“Happiness”
“Freedom”

Negative Descriptions (what it’s NOT):

Unconditioned (not dependent on causes)
Unborn, unoriginated, uncreated
No craving, hatred, delusion
No suffering

UPSC Point: Nirvana concept shows limits of language and conceptual thought in capturing ultimate reality. Appeals to mystical, experiential dimension while maintaining rational, empirical approach. Not nihilistic void but positive state beyond description.

4. KEY BUDDHIST CONCEPTS (Additional Doctrines)

A. ANATTA (Non-Self/No-Soul):

Most Revolutionary Buddhist Teaching – distinguishes Buddhism from Hinduism

Hindu View (Upanishadic):

Atman (eternal soul/self) exists
Atman = Brahman (individual soul = universal soul)
Liberation = Realization of Atman

Buddhist View:

NO permanent, unchanging self/soul
What we call “self” is:
- Five Aggregates (Pancaskandha):
  1. Rupa (Form/Body): Physical body, material
  2. Vedana (Sensation/Feeling): Pleasant, unpleasant, neutral
  3. Sanna (Perception): Recognition, identification
  4. Sankhara (Mental formations): Volitions, emotions, thoughts
  5. Vinnana (Consciousness): Awareness through six senses
All five aggregates are impermanent, changing
None can be “self” because all are conditioned, dependent
“Self” is conventional designation, not ultimate reality
Like chariot: Collection of parts, no “chariot essence” beyond parts

Anatta Implications:

No eternal soul transmigrating
What rebirths? Continuity of mental stream (like flame passing from candle to candle), not soul migration
Who attains Nirvana? Process ends, not person
Liberation from self-view, pride, conceit

UPSC Relevance:

Challenges essentialism (fixed identities)
Fluid, process-based view of reality
Psychological freedom from ego
Basis for Buddhist ethics (interconnectedness)

B. ANICCA (Impermanence):

Everything conditioned is impermanent

“All compounded things are subject to decay”
Nothing lasts forever – bodies, relationships, empires, planets
Moment-to-moment flux
Heraclitus’s “River”: Can’t step in same river twice

Three Levels:

Gross impermanence: Birth-death cycle obvious
Subtle impermanence: Aging process moment-to-moment
Momentary impermanence: Mental/physical phenomena arising-passing each instant

Meditation on Impermanence:

Seeing arising (Uppada), staying (Thiti), passing (Vaya) of phenomena
Develops non-attachment
Prepares for insight into Anatta

UPSC Application:

Acceptance of change
Adaptability in policy-making
Letting go of past glories
Preparing for future challenges

C. DUKKHA (Already covered in First Noble Truth)

Together: Ti-Lakkhana (Three Characteristics) – Anicca, Dukkha, Anatta

Seeing these three in all phenomena = Insight leading to liberation

D. PRATITYASAMUTPADA (Dependent Origination):

“This being, that becomes; from arising of this, that arises”

Nothing exists independently
All phenomena arise dependent on conditions
Mutual causation, not linear
No first cause (rejects Creator God)

12-Link Chain (already listed in Second Noble Truth):

Shows how ignorance leads to suffering through chain of dependent causation
Breaking chain at any link stops suffering

UPSC Significance:

Systems thinking: Everything interconnected
Environmental ethics: Harm to one part affects whole
Social interdependence: Individual-society mutual shaping
Policy implications: Holistic, multi-causal analysis

E. KARMA and REBIRTH:

Karma (Kamma in Pali):

Volitional action (mental, verbal, physical)
Intention most important (accidental acts less karmically weighty)
Creates karmic imprint (Sankara) → future consequences

Three Types:

Kaya-karma: Bodily action
Vaci-karma: Verbal action
Mano-karma: Mental action (thoughts!) – most important

Karmic Results:

Kusala karma (Wholesome): Happiness, good rebirth
Akusala karma (Unwholesome): Suffering, bad rebirth
Abyakata karma (Neutral): No significant result

Rebirth:

Samsara (cycle of rebirth) continues until Nirvana
Six Realms (traditional):
1. Deva (gods) – heavenly, temporary
2. Asura (demi-gods) – jealous, warlike
3. Manusya (humans) – best for enlightenment!
4. Tiryak (animals)
5. Preta (hungry ghosts)
6. Naraka (hell beings)
Rebirth determined by karma
But: No soul transmigrates! (See Anatta)

Buddhist Innovation:

Karma not deterministic (unlike Jainism, Ajivikas)
Present actions matter – can change destiny
Human rebirth precious – only realm where enlightenment possible (gods too comfortable, hell beings too suffering)

UPSC Ethical Implications:

Moral responsibility: Actions have consequences
Hope: Bad present doesn’t determine future (can change through effort)
Equality: All beings have Buddha-nature, can be liberated

C. BUDDHIST COUNCILS (Sanghas)

Councils convened to:

Preserve Buddha’s teachings (originally oral)
Resolve doctrinal disputes
Maintain Sangha discipline (Vinaya)

FIRST BUDDHIST COUNCIL:

Date: 483 BCE (shortly after Buddha’s Parinirvana) Place: Rajagriha (Rajgir), Bihar Convener: Mahakashyapa (senior disciple) Patron: King Ajatashatru (Magadha) Participants: 500 Arhats (enlightened monks)

Purpose:

Preserve Buddha’s teachings before memory fades
Settle any doubts

Proceedings:

Ananda (Buddha’s attendant) recited Suttas (Discourses)
- “Thus have I heard…” (Evam me sutam)
- Organized by length: Digha Nikaya, Majjhima Nikaya, etc.
Upali recited Vinaya (Monastic discipline)
- Rules for monks/nuns
- Procedures for ordination, confession, expulsion
Both approved by assembly

Result:

Oral tradition established
Tripitaka (Three Baskets) structure formed (written down centuries later)

Controversy:

Some monks (led by Purana) rejected codification: “I prefer to remember as I heard from Buddha directly”
Seeds of later schism

SECOND BUDDHIST COUNCIL:

Date: ~383 BCE (100 years after Parinirvana) Place: Vaishali, Bihar
Convener: Monk Yashas Patron: King Kalashoka (disputed) Participants: 700 monks

Cause: 10 Points Controversy

The Dispute:

Vaishali monks (Vajjiputtakas) adopted 10 “lax” practices:
1. Storing salt in horn (for future use)
2. Eating after midday (monks should eat before noon only)
3. Eating in village then going to another (second meal)
4. Holding separate Uposatha (fortnightly meetings) within same boundary
5. Carrying out acts requiring Sangha approval without full assembly
6. Following practices because teacher did (blind tradition)
7. Eating sour milk after meals
8. Drinking unfermented wine
9. Using mats with fringe
10. Accepting gold and silver (money) – most contentious!

Proceedings:

Debate on whether these practices allowed
Elders (Theras) led by Yashas: Rejected all 10 (strict interpretation of Vinaya)
Vajjiputtakas: Defended practices (lax interpretation)

Decision:

All 10 practices condemned
Orthodox position upheld

Aftermath – FIRST SCHISM:

Vaishali monks refused to accept
Held separate council (Maha Sangiti)
Buddhism split:
1. Sthaviravada (Theravada) – Elders, orthodox, strict
2. Mahasanghika – Great Assembly, liberal, lax
Beginning of sectarian divisions

Significance: Shows tension between rigidity and flexibility, monasticism and lay engagement

THIRD BUDDHIST COUNCIL:

Date: ~250 BCE (during Ashoka’s reign) Place: Pataliputra (Patna), Bihar Convener: Monk Moggaliputta Tissa (Ashoka’s teacher) Patron: Emperor Ashoka Participants: 1,000 monks

Context:

Ashoka’s patronage → Buddhism immensely popular
Many joined Sangha for material benefits (not spiritual reasons) – quality decline
Heretical views creeping in

Purpose:

Purify Sangha (expel fake monks)
Settle doctrinal disputes
Compile authentic teachings

Proceedings:

Expelled monks with wrong views (Ajivika, materialist ideas)
Confirmed Vibhajjavada (Discriminating Doctrine) as orthodox:
- Middle way between eternalism and nihilism
- Some questions answerable, some not
- Analytical approach
Compiled Abhidhamma Pitaka (Philosophical Psychology)
- Systematic analysis of Buddha’s teachings
- Classification of mental states, processes

Kathavatthu (Points of Controversy):

Moggaliputta Tissa wrote this text
Refuted 250+ heretical views
Established orthodox positions

Missionary Activity:

Ashoka sent missionaries to spread Buddhism:
- Sri Lanka: Mahinda (Ashoka’s son/brother), Sanghamitta (daughter)
- Southeast Asia: Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia
- Central Asia: Bactria, Gandhara
- West: Egypt, Syria, Greece (limited success)
- East: China (via Silk Road)

Significance:

Buddhism transformed from Indian religion to world religion
Theravada tradition dominant (preserved in Pali Canon)
Ashoka’s rock edicts spread Dhamma

FOURTH BUDDHIST COUNCIL (Controversial – not recognized by all traditions):

Two Versions:

Version 1 (Theravada – in Sri Lanka):

Date: ~29 BCE (1st Century BCE)
Place: Aluvihara, Sri Lanka
Purpose: First written recording of Tripitaka
- Until then, purely oral tradition (500 years!)
- Fear of loss (famine, war)
- Monks wrote on palm leaves in Pali language
Result: Pali Canon (Tipitaka) preserved in writing

Version 2 (Sarvastivada – in Kashmir):

Date: ~100 CE (1st-2nd Century CE)
Place: Kundalavana (Jalandhar or Kashmir)
Convener: Vasumitra, Ashvaghosha
Patron: Kanishka (Kushana Emperor)
Purpose:
- Compile Sarvastivada school’s texts
- Resolve Hinayana-Mahayana debates
- Commentaries on Tripitaka

Proceedings:

Compiled Mahavibhasa (Great Commentary) on Abhidhamma
Written in Sanskrit (not Pali)
Mahayana sutras likely discussed/promoted

Significance:

Sanskrit Buddhist texts begin (alongside Pali)
Mahayana Buddhism gains imperial patronage
Buddhism spreads to Central Asia, China (via Silk Road)
Gandhara and Mathura art schools flourish under Kanishka

SUMMARY TABLE – Buddhist Councils:

Council	Date	Place	Convener	Patron	Key Outcome
First	483 BCE	Rajagriha	Mahakashyapa	Ajatashatru	Oral compilation: Sutta, Vinaya
Second	383 BCE	Vaishali	Yashas	Kalashoka	10 Points condemned; First Schism (Theravada vs. Mahasanghika)
Third	250 BCE	Pataliputra	Moggaliputta Tissa	Ashoka	Purification; Abhidhamma; Missions abroad
Fourth (Theravada)	29 BCE	Sri Lanka (Aluvihara)	–	–	Pali Canon written down
Fourth (Sarvastivada)	100 CE	Kashmir	Vasumitra	Kanishka	Sanskrit texts; Mahayana support

UPSC Importance:

Shows institutionalization of religion
Textual preservation methods (oral → written)
Patronage role (kings like Ashoka, Kanishka)
Schisms and evolution (unity → diversity)
Internationalization (local → global)

D. SANGHA ORGANIZATION

Sangha (Samgha in Pali): Community of Buddhist monks and nuns

Two Aspects:

Arya Sangha: Those who’ve attained enlightenment stages (Stream-winner, Once-returner, Non-returner, Arhat)
Conventional Sangha: All ordained monks (Bhikkhu) and nuns (Bhikkhuni)

Admission:

Open to all – revolutionary!
No caste, gender (initially), class discrimination
Requirements:
- Minimum age (usually 20 for full ordination)
- Free from debts, diseases (some)
- Parental/spousal permission
- Sincere intention

Ordination Ceremony:

Pabbajja (Going forth): Novice ordination (Saman# Buddhism and Heterodox Movements in Ancient India

E. THERAVADA VS. MAHAYANA BUDDHISM

Second Major Schism (after Theravada-Mahasanghika split)

Timeline: Gradual divergence ~1st Century BCE to 1st Century CE

THERAVADA (“Teaching of Elders”):

Origin:

Developed from Sthaviravada branch (Second Council split)
Preserved in Pali Canon (Tipitaka)
Remained closer to original teachings

Geography: Southern Buddhism

Sri Lanka (stronghold since Ashoka’s mission)
Myanmar (Burma)
Thailand
Cambodia
Laos
Parts of Vietnam, Bangladesh

Core Beliefs:

1. Goal: Arhat (Personal enlightenment)

Individual liberation (escape Samsara)
Focus on monks achieving Nirvana
“Save yourself first”

2. Buddha’s Nature:

Historical teacher (Gautama Buddha)
Human who achieved enlightenment
Not god, not supernatural (though revered)
No other Buddhas worshipped

3. Bodhisattva Ideal: Not emphasized

Admire Buddha’s quest but aim for personal Arhat-hood
Bodhisattva path too difficult, too long

4. Scriptures: Pali Canon only (Tipitaka)

Sutta Pitaka (Discourses)
Vinaya Pitaka (Discipline)
Abhidhamma Pitaka (Philosophy)
Conservative: No new sutras accepted

5. Path: Original Eightfold Path

Emphasis on monasticism
Lay practice supportive but monks primary practitioners
Meditation central (Vipassana)

6. Philosophy:

Conservative, orthodox
Psychological analysis
Abhidhamma scholasticism
Focus on phenomenology (what exists)

7. Rituals: Minimal

Meditation primary practice
Offerings to Buddha (gratitude, not worship)
Chanting Pali sutras

8. Art:

Simple: Buddha images (meditation pose)
Stupas: Containing relics
Monastic architecture

Modern Strongholds: Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Thailand (state religion)

MAHAYANA (“Great Vehicle”):

Origin:

Developed from Mahasanghika branch + new ideas
Around 1st Century CE
Sanskrit texts (not Pali)

Geography: Northern/Eastern Buddhism

China
Japan (Zen, Pure Land)
Korea
Vietnam
Tibet (Vajrayana, form of Mahayana)
Mongolia

Core Beliefs:

1. Goal: Bodhisattva path

Universal liberation (save all beings)
Postpone own Nirvana to help others
Compassion (Karuna) central
“Save everyone together”

2. Buddha’s Nature:

Cosmic, transcendent beings
Multiple Buddhas: Past (Dipankara), Present (Shakyamuni), Future (Maitreya), Celestial (Amitabha, Medicine Buddha, etc.)
Trikaya (Three Bodies) doctrine:
1. Dharmakaya: Ultimate Buddha-nature (truth body)
2. Sambhogakaya: Bliss body (celestial Buddhas)
3. Nirmanakaya: Emanation body (historical Buddha)
Buddha-nature (Tathagatagarbha) in all beings

3. Bodhisattva Ideal: Central

Avalokiteshvara (Compassion)
Manjushri (Wisdom)
Ksitigarbha (Vow to empty hells)
Tara (Female Bodhisattva)
Worshipped, invoked for help

4. Scriptures: Pali Canon + Mahayana Sutras

Prajnaparamita Sutras (Perfection of Wisdom) – Heart Sutra, Diamond Sutra
Lotus Sutra (Saddharma Pundarika)
Lankavatara Sutra
Vimalakirti Sutra
Avatamsaka Sutra
Hundreds of new texts

5. Path: Six Perfections (Paramitas)

Dana (Generosity)
Sila (Morality)
Ksanti (Patience)
Virya (Energy)
Dhyana (Meditation)
Prajna (Wisdom)

Plus 4 more in some versions (Method, Vow, Power, Knowledge)

6. Philosophy: Sunyata (Emptiness)

Madhyamaka school (Nagarjuna, 2nd Century CE):
- All phenomena “empty” of inherent existence
- Dependent origination ultimate truth
- Middle Way between existence and non-existence
Yogachara school (Asanga, Vasubandhu, 4th Century CE):
- “Mind-only” (Vijnanavada)
- External world is mental projection
- Storehouse consciousness (Alaya-vijnana)

7. Rituals: Elaborate

Devotional practices: Chanting sutras, prostrations
Visualization: Of Buddhas, Bodhisattvas, mandalas
Mantras: Sacred sounds (Om Mani Padme Hum)
Merit transfer: Dedicate merit to others
Pure Land practice: Faith in Amitabha Buddha → rebirth in Pure Land (easier path to enlightenment)

8. Art:

Elaborate: Multiple Buddha images, Bodhisattvas
Iconography: Rich symbolism (mudras, colors, implements)
Thangkas (Tibetan Buddhist paintings)
Mandalas: Sacred geometric designs

Lay Emphasis:

Laypeople can achieve Bodhisattva path
Not exclusively monastic
Democratization of enlightenment

Schools:

Zen (Japan, China – Chan): Meditation, sudden enlightenment
Pure Land: Faith in Amitabha Buddha
Tibetan (Vajrayana): Tantric practices, lamas, tulkus (reincarnate lamas)
Nichiren: Lotus Sutra focus

COMPARISON TABLE:

Aspect	Theravada	Mahayana
Meaning	Teaching of Elders	Great Vehicle
Language	Pali	Sanskrit, Chinese, Tibetan
Scripture	Pali Canon only	Pali Canon + Mahayana Sutras
Geography	South/Southeast Asia	East Asia, Tibet
Goal	Arhat (personal enlightenment)	Bodhisattva (universal salvation)
Buddha	Historical teacher	Cosmic, multiple Buddhas
Emphasis	Individual liberation	Compassion for all beings
Practice	Monasticism central	Lay practice valued equally
Philosophy	Conservative, Abhidhamma	Sunyata (Emptiness), Tathagatagarbha
Rituals	Minimal	Elaborate devotions
Path	Eightfold Path	Six Perfections (Paramitas)
Art	Simple Buddha images	Elaborate iconography
Approach	Gradual, individual effort	Sudden enlightenment possible; grace (Pure Land)

Mutual Criticism:

Mahayana calls Theravada: “Hinayana” (Lesser Vehicle) – self-centered, too conservative (Theravada rejects this term)
Theravada calls Mahayana: Too deviant from original teachings, too ritualistic, diluted Buddha’s message

UPSC Balanced View:

Both are authentic Buddhist traditions
Differences reflect adaptation to different cultures:
- Theravada suited to Pali-speaking Indianized Southeast Asia
- Mahayana suited to Confucian/Taoist China, Shinto Japan, Bon Tibet
Common core: Four Noble Truths, Eightfold Path, Karma, Rebirth, Nirvana, No-Self
Unity in diversity: Buddhism’s strength

Third Major Tradition: Vajrayana (Tibetan Buddhism)

Form of Mahayana with Tantric elements
Tibet, Bhutan, Mongolia, Ladakh
Dalai Lama, Tibetan Book of the Dead
Mandalas, mantras, mudras, visualizations
Guru-disciple transmission

F. DECLINE OF BUDDHISM IN INDIA (Paradox: Flourished Abroad, Died at Home)

Peak: 3rd Century BCE (Ashoka) to 7th Century CE (Harsha) Decline: 8th-12th Century CE Near Extinction: By 13th Century CE (except pockets)

Multi-Causal Decline (UPSC Analytical Framework):

1. INTERNAL FACTORS (Within Buddhism):

A. Monasticism vs. Lay Life:

Over-emphasis on monasticism (especially Theravada)
Monks became removed from society
Laypeople felt excluded from higher practices
Monasteries accumulated wealth (land grants)
Corruption: Monks lived comfortably, not ascetically
Lost original spirit of simplicity

B. Doctrinal Complexity:

Abhidhamma philosophy became too abstract (Theravada)
Mahayana philosophy (Sunyata, Yogachara) intellectually demanding
Ordinary people couldn’t understand
Alienation of masses

C. Sectarian Divisions:

18+ schools by 2nd Century CE
Theravada vs. Mahayana schism
Internal conflicts, mutual criticism
Weakened unity, confused followers

D. Degeneration of Sangha:

Disciplinary laxity: Vinaya rules neglected
Material comfort: Wealthy monasteries, monks not practicing
Loss of respect: Corruption scandals
Decline in meditation: More focus on rituals, texts than practice

E. Absorption of Hindu Elements:

Tantric Buddhism (Vajrayana) incorporated rituals similar to Hinduism
Buddha deified (Mahayana) – like Hindu gods
Rituals resembled Hindu pujas
Distinction blurred → People saw no difference
Hindu revivalists argued: Why not worship traditional gods?

2. EXTERNAL FACTORS (Hindu Response):

A. Bhakti Movement (6th-15th Century CE):

Counter to Buddhism: Personal devotion to Hindu gods
Accessible: Vernacular languages, emotional appeal
Inclusive: All castes welcome (like Buddhism)
Competitive: Offered same benefits (devotion, salvation) without rejecting Vedas
Saints: Ramanuja, Madhva, Ramananda, Kabir, Chaitanya
Absorbed Buddhist ethical teachings into Hinduism

B. Shankaracharya’s Advaita Vedanta (8th Century CE):

Philosophical challenge: Advaita (non-dualism) intellectually sophisticated
Debated Buddhists: Defeated in public debates (tradition)
Synthesized: Incorporated some Buddhist ideas (Maya, meditation)
Established mathas: Four cardinal directions (institutional counter)
Argued: Buddha’s teachings already in Upanishads
“Buddha is Vishnu’s avatar”: Absorbed Buddha into Hindu pantheon

C. Brahmanical Revival:

Smriti literature: Reinforced Varna, rituals
Puranas: Popularized Hindu gods’ stories
Temple construction: Magnificent temples (Khajuraho, Konark, Thanjavur) – visual competition with Buddhist stupas
Royal patronage shift: Gupta, Pallava, Chola kings favored Hinduism
Brahmin regained dominance: In courts, education

D. Integration/Assimilation:

Buddha made 9th avatar of Vishnu (Dashavatara)
- “Buddha came to delude demons by teaching non-violence”
- Clever strategy: Respect Buddha but reject teachings
Buddhist sites became Hindu: Bodh Gaya controlled by Mahants (Hindu priests)
Buddhist practices Hinduized: Yoga, meditation absorbed
Buddhist ethics incorporated: Ahimsa, compassion emphasized in Hinduism

3. POLITICAL FACTORS:

A. Loss of Royal Patronage:

Ashoka (3rd Century BCE): Greatest patron
Kanishka (1st-2nd Century CE): Supported Mahayana
Harsha (7th Century CE): Last major patron
After Harsha: Hindu dynasties dominated
- Chalukyas, Rashtrakutas, Palas (partially Buddhist), Pratiharas, Cholas → Favored Hinduism
No state support: Monasteries declined, no new constructions

B. Destruction of Monasteries:

Hun Invasions (5th-6th Century CE): Damaged monasteries
Turkish Invasions (12th-13th Century CE): Catastrophic
- Muhammad Ghori, Bakhtiyar Khilji, Qutbuddin Aibak
- Nalanda University destroyed (~1193 CE by Bakhtiyar Khilji)
  - Burned for 3 months (legend)
  - Thousands of monks killed/fled
- Vikramashila destroyed (12th Century CE)
- Odantapuri destroyed
- Libraries burned: Irreplaceable manuscripts lost
Monasteries were:
- Wealthy (easy targets for plunder)
- Centralized (one attack destroyed entire complex)
- Non-violent (couldn’t defend themselves – Ahimsa)

C. Lack of Lay Support:

Monasteries depended on royal/merchant donations
With royal patronage gone, couldn’t sustain
Laypeople shifted to Hinduism (Bhakti more accessible)

4. SOCIO-ECONOMIC FACTORS:

A. Feudalism Rise:

Land grants to Brahmins (Agrahara, Brahmadeya)
Brahmin landlords dominated villages
Buddhist monks lost rural support base

B. Caste System Resurgence:

Buddhism’s anti-caste message weakened over time
Hindu society re-stratified rigidly (smriti literature)
Buddhist monks came from all castes but couldn’t change society alone

C. Trade Decline:

Merchants were Buddhism’s main supporters
Urban decline (post-Gupta)
Trade routes disrupted (Hun invasions)
Merchant class weakened → Less support for Buddhism

D. Language Shift:

Pali ceased to be spoken language
Sanskrit revived (Hindu texts)
Apabhramsha emerged (precursors to modern Indian languages)
Buddhist texts in Pali/Sanskrit → Disconnected from masses

5. CULTURAL FACTORS:

A. Buddhism’s Non-Confrontational Nature:

Emphasis on peace, non-violence
Didn’t fight back against Hindu revivalism
No militant defense of monasteries (unlike later Shaolin monks in China!)
Passive absorption

B. Lack of Social Engagement (Later Period):

Early Buddhism addressed social issues (caste, rituals)
Later Buddhism became monastery-centered
Monks disconnected from social problems
Hinduism more socially embedded (family rituals, festivals, temples)

C. Women’s Exclusion (Gradually):

Bhikkhuni Sangha declined faster than Bhikkhu
Eight Garudhamma rules created inequality
Ordination lineage broken: No Theravada bhikkhunis today (restoration efforts ongoing)
Lost women’s support

6. GEOGRAPHICAL SPREAD PARADOX:

Buddhism spread abroad: Sri Lanka, Southeast Asia, Central Asia, China, Japan, Tibet
International success → Reduced focus on India
Monastic resources went to foreign missions
Intellectuals, teachers migrated (Bodhidharma to China, Padmasambhava to Tibet)
Brain drain from India

SURVIVAL POCKETS (Until Modern Revival):

Himalayan Regions:
- Ladakh, Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh: Vajrayana survived
- Remote, protected from invasions
Tribal Belts:
- Some tribal groups retained Buddhist practices (mixed with animism)
Nepal:
- Birthplace of Buddha
- Newar Buddhism (unique form) survived
Chittagong (Bangladesh):
- Barua Buddhist community

MODERN REVIVAL (19th-20th Century):

Colonial Period:

Rediscovery: British archaeologists (Alexander Cunningham, James Prinsep)
Excavations: Sanchi, Sarnath, Bodh Gaya, Nalanda
Decipherment: Brahmi script, Ashoka’s edicts
Buddhist heritage reclaimed

B.R. Ambedkar’s Mass Conversion (1956):

Dalit leader: Converted to Buddhism (Deeksha Bhumi, Nagpur)
500,000 followers converted with him
Reason: Escape Hindu caste oppression, dignity, equality
Navayana Buddhism: “New Vehicle” – focus on social justice
Millions converted since
Buddhism revived as social reform movement

Tibetan Refugees (1959):

Dalai Lama fled Chinese invasion
100,000+ Tibetans in India (Dharamshala, Bylakuppe, etc.)
Revitalized Vajrayana in India
Global interest in Tibetan Buddhism

Vipassana Movement:

S.N. Goenka: Popularized Vipassana meditation
Non-sectarian, secular mindfulness
Global spread (including West)

Tourism:

Buddhist Circuit: Lumbini, Bodh Gaya, Sarnath, Kushinagara
International pilgrims (from Buddhist countries)
Economic revival of sites

Current Status:

0.7% of Indian population (~8 million, Census 2011)
Concentrated: Maharashtra (Ambedkarite), Ladakh, Sikkim, Arunachal Pradesh
Growing globally: 500+ million worldwide

UPSC SYNTHESIS – WHY DECLINE MATTERS:

Lessons:

Institutionalization dilemma: Success → Wealth → Corruption → Decline (applicable to all institutions)
Elite disconnect: Intellectualism alienates masses (policy lesson)
Flexibility vs. Rigidity: Hinduism adapted (Bhakti), Buddhism didn’t (in India)
Social engagement: Religions/ideologies must address social needs
External threats: Violence can destroy even great civilizations (Nalanda burning)
Revival possible: Ambedkar’s movement shows ideals can be reclaimed

Contemporary Relevance:

Buddhist values (non-violence, compassion, mindfulness) globally influential
Soft power: India’s Buddhist diplomacy (Asia, especially East/Southeast)
Cultural heritage: Tourism, UNESCO sites
Social reform: Ambedkarite Buddhism continues fighting caste
Interfaith dialogue: Buddhism’s rationalism, non-dogmatism valued

III. EXAMINATION STRATEGY AND ANSWER FRAMEWORKS

A. Types of Questions on Buddhism

1. Biographical Questions:

Example: “Discuss the life and teachings of Gautama Buddha.” (250 words, 15 marks)

Structure:

Introduction (40 words): Context (6th Century BCE crisis), Buddha’s significance
Life (70 words): Birth (Lumbini, Shakya clan), Four Sights, Renunciation, Six years seeking, Enlightenment (Bodh Gaya), First Sermon (Sarnath), 45 years teaching, Parinirvana (Kushinagara)
Teachings (100 words):
- Four Noble Truths (Dukkha, Samudaya, Nirodha, Magga)
- Eightfold Path (brief overview)
- Key concepts: Anatta, Anicca, Pratityasamutpada, Karma
- Middle Way, practical ethics
Conclusion (40 words): Significance – challenged Brahminism, emphasized rationality/compassion, founded world religion, influenced Indian/Asian culture profoundly

2. Doctrinal Questions:

Example: “Explain the Four Noble Truths and Eightfold Path in Buddhism.” (150 words, 10 marks)

Structure:

Introduction (20 words): Core of Buddha’s teachings, practical path to liberation
Four Noble Truths (60 words):
- Dukkha (suffering exists)
- Samudaya (craving causes suffering)
- Nirodha (suffering can end – Nirvana)
- Magga (Eightfold Path is the way)
Eightfold Path (50 words):
- Prajna: Right View, Right Intention
- Sila: Right Speech, Right Action, Right Livelihood
- Samadhi: Right Effort, Right Mindfulness, Right Concentration
Conclusion (20 words): Holistic development (wisdom, ethics, meditation), practical and empirical, accessible to all

3. Comparative Questions:

Example: “Compare Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism.” (150 words, 10 marks)

Use Table (saves words, shows clarity):

Aspect	Theravada	Mahayana
Meaning	Teaching of Elders	Great Vehicle
Geography	South/Southeast Asia	East Asia, Tibet
Goal	Arhat (individual)	Bodhisattva (universal)
Buddha	Historical teacher	Cosmic, multiple
Scriptures	Pali Canon	+ Mahayana Sutras
Practice	Monastic focus	Lay emphasis too
Philosophy	Conservative	Sunyata, Tathagatagarbha

Analysis (50 words): Theravada conservative, closer to original; Mahayana innovative, adapted to new cultures. Both share core (Four Noble Truths, Karma, Nirvana). Differences reflect cultural adaptation, not fundamental contradiction. Unity in diversity strengthens Buddhism.

4. Historical Questions:

Example: “Analyze the factors responsible for the decline of Buddhism in India.” (250 words, 15 marks)

Structure:

Introduction (30 words): Paradox – flourished abroad, declined at home; peak under Ashoka, near extinction by 13th Century
Body (180 words) – Multi-causal:
- Internal: Monastic elitism, doctrinal complexity, sectarian divisions, corruption, Tantric absorption into Hinduism
- External – Hindu Response: Bhakti movement, Shankaracharya’s Advaita, Brahmanical revival, absorption (Buddha as Vishnu avatar)
- Political: Loss of royal patronage (post-Harsha), Turkish invasions (Nalanda destroyed 1193 CE), monastery vulnerability
- Socio-Economic: Feudalism, caste resurgence, trade decline, merchant class weakening
- Cultural: Non-confrontational nature, disconnection from masses, language shift (Pali obsolete)
Conclusion (40 words): No single cause but interaction of factors; greatest blow was destruction of universities (Nalanda, Vikramashila) and loss of intellectual tradition; Modern revival (Ambedkar 1956) as social reform shows ideas endure

5. Contemporary Relevance Questions:

Example: “Discuss the contemporary relevance of Buddhist philosophy.” (150 words, 10 marks)

Structure:

Introduction (25 words): Ancient wisdom applicable to modern challenges
Body (100 words):
- Mental Health: Mindfulness for stress, anxiety, depression; Vipassana globally used
- Ethics: Ahimsa (non-violence) relevant for conflict resolution, peace
- Environment: Interdependence (Pratityasamutpada) supports ecological thinking
- Social Justice: Anti-caste, equality principles (Ambedkar’s use)
- Rationalism: Empirical, non-dogmatic approach appeals to scientific mindset
- Middle Way: Avoiding extremes (policy, personal life)
- Soft Power: India’s Buddhist diplomacy (Asia outreach)
Conclusion (25 words): Buddhism’s emphasis on compassion, mindfulness, rational inquiry makes it relevant; not just religion but practical philosophy for living

B. Key Points for Quick Revision

BUDDHISM ESSENTIALS:

✅ Buddha’s Life (8 Key Events):

Birth: Lumbini, 563 BCE, Shakya clan
Four Sights: Old, sick, dead, ascetic
Renunciation: Age 29, left palace
Seeking: 6 years (teachers, asceticism)
Enlightenment: Bodh Gaya, age 35
First Sermon: Sarnath (Dharmachakra Pravartana)
Teaching: 45 years, Middle Gangetic plains
Parinirvana: Kushinagara, age 80

✅ Four Noble Truths: Dukkha → Samudaya (Tanha) → Nirodha (Nirvana) → Magga (Eightfold Path)

✅ Eightfold Path (3 Groups):

Prajna: Right View, Right Intention
Sila: Right Speech, Action, Livelihood
Samadhi: Right Effort, Mindfulness, Concentration

✅ Key Concepts:

Anatta (No-Self)
Anicca (Impermanence)
Dukkha (Suffering)
Pratityasamutpada (Dependent Origination)
Nirvana (Liberation, “blowing out” craving)

✅ Four Buddhist Councils:

First (483 BCE, Rajagriha): Compilation (Sutta, Vinaya)
Second (383 BCE, Vaishali): Schism (Theravada vs. Mahasanghika)
Third (250 BCE, Pataliputra, Ashoka): Missions abroad, – Death: Contemplating corpse in stages of decay (Maranasati) – impermanence
Vedananupassana (Mindfulness of Feelings/Sensations):
- Pleasant, unpleasant, neutral sensations
- Observe without reacting (key practice!)
- See arising and passing of feelings
- Breaks automatic reaction chain (feeling → craving → suffering)
Cittanupassana (Mindfulness of Mind/Mental States):
- Aware of mind with/without greed, hatred, delusion
- Concentrated or distracted
- Expansive or contracted
- Observing observer – meta-awareness
Dhammanupassana (Mindfulness of Mental Objects/Phenomena):
- Five Hindrances: Sensual desire, ill-will, sloth, restlessness, doubt
- Seven Factors of Enlightenment: Mindfulness, investigation, energy, joy, tranquility, concentration, equanimity
- Four Noble Truths: Direct contemplation

Modern Application: Vipassana meditation (insight meditation) based on Satipatthana

S.N. Goenka popularized globally
Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) in West
Clinical psychology applications

8. SAMMA SAMADHI (Right Concentration):

Definition: One-pointed, focused mind; deep meditative absorption

Four Jhanas (Meditative Absorptions):

First Jhana:

Directed thought (Vitakka), sustained thought (Vicara)
Joy (Piti), happiness (Sukha)
One-pointedness
Seclusion from sensual pleasures

Second Jhana:

Directed/sustained thought ceases
Internal confidence, unification of mind
Joy and happiness remain

Third Jhana:

Joy fades
Equanimity arises
Happiness continues
Mindfulness and clear comprehension

Fourth Jhana:

Happiness ceases
Pure equanimity and mindfulness
Neither pleasure nor pain
Profound peace

Beyond Jhanas: Formless Absorptions (Arupa Jhanas):

Sphere of Infinite Space
Sphere of Infinite Consciousness
Sphere of Nothingness
Sphere of Neither Perception nor Non-Perception

But: Even highest jhanas are not Nirvana – temporary states

Insight (Vipassana) needed along with Concentration (Samatha)
Concentration calms mind; Insight liberates

Samadhi’s Role:

Purifies mind
Develops psychic powers (Abhinna) – but not goal
Prepares for liberating insight

EIGHTFOLD PATH – Summary Table:

Factor	Pali Term	Training	Focus	Practical Application
1. Right View	Samma Ditthi	Prajna (Wisdom)	Understanding reality	Study Four Noble Truths
2. Right Intention	Samma Sankappa	Prajna (Wisdom)	Wholesome motivation	Cultivate renunciation, goodwill, compassion
3. Right Speech	Samma Vaca	Sila (Morality)	Ethical communication	Truth, harmony, gentleness, purpose
4. Right Action	Samma Kammanta	Sila (Morality)	Ethical conduct	Five/Ten Precepts
5. Right Livelihood	Samma Ajiva	Sila (Morality)	Ethical work	Harmless profession
6. Right Effort	Samma Vayama	Samadhi (Meditation)	Mental energy	Prevent/abandon unwholesome, cultivate/maintain wholesome
7. Right Mindfulness	Samma Sati	Samadhi (Meditation)	Present awareness	Four Foundations (body, feelings, mind, phenomena)
8. Right Concentration	Samma Samadhi	Samadhi (Meditation)	One-pointed focus	Four Jhanas, meditative absorption

UPSC Significance:

Practical, actionable path – not abstract philosophy
Holistic development: Wisdom, ethics, meditation together
Gradual training: Accessible to all, step-by-step
Empirically verifiable: Results testable through practice
Universal applicability: For monks and laypeople
Middle Way exemplified: Avoiding extremes in each factor
Relevant today: Mindfulness, ethical living, mental health

CONCEPT OF NIRVANA (Nibbana)

Already covered in Third Noble Truth, but deeper analysis:

Philosophical Questions:

Q: Does enlightened person exist after death? Buddha’s Answer: Unanswerable (Avyakata) – question wrongly framed

Why Unanswerable?:

Assumes permanent “person” exists (violates Anatta)
“Exist” and “not exist” are conceptual categories
Nirvana transcends concepts
Like asking: “Where does flame go when candle extinguished?”
- Doesn’t go anywhere – conditions for flame cease
- Similarly, conditions for rebirth (craving, ignorance) cease

Buddha’s Simile:

Ocean (Nirvana) is beyond measurement
Don’t ask: “How deep?” – immeasurable
Can only know by diving in (experiencing)

Two Truths Doctrine (Mahayana development):

Conventional Truth (Samvr̥ti-satya): Ordinary language, concepts (person, self, existence)
Ultimate Truth (Paramārtha-satya): Reality beyond concepts (Nirvana, Emptiness)
Nirvana can’t be captured in conventional language

Positive Descriptions (Buddha used):

“Island amidst flood”
“Refuge”
“Deathless”
“Peace”
“Happiness”
“Freedom”

Negative Descriptions (what it’s NOT):

Unconditioned (not dependent on causes)
Unborn, unoriginated, uncreated
No craving, hatred, delusion
No suffering

KEY BUDDHIST CONCEPTS (Additional Doctrines)

A. ANATTA (Non-Self/No-Soul):

Most Revolutionary Buddhist Teaching – distinguishes Buddhism from Hinduism

Hindu View (Upanishadic):

Atman (eternal soul/self) exists
Atman = Brahman (individual soul = universal soul)
Liberation = Realization of Atman

Buddhist View:

NO permanent, unchanging self/soul
What we call “self” is:
- Five Aggregates (Pancaskandha):
  1. Rupa (Form/Body): Physical body, material
  2. Vedana (Sensation/Feeling): Pleasant, unpleasant, neutral
  3. Sanna (Perception): Recognition, identification
  4. Sankhara (Mental formations): Volitions, emotions, thoughts
  5. Vinnana (Consciousness): Awareness through six senses
All five aggregates are impermanent, changing
None can be “self” because all are conditioned, dependent
“Self” is conventional designation, not ultimate reality
Like chariot: Collection of parts, no “chariot essence” beyond parts

Anatta Implications:

No eternal soul transmigrating
What rebirths? Continuity of mental stream (like flame passing from candle to candle), not soul migration
Who attains Nirvana? Process ends, not person
Liberation from self-view, pride, conceit

UPSC Relevance:

Challenges essentialism (fixed identities)
Fluid, process-based view of reality
Psychological freedom from ego
Basis for Buddhist ethics (interconnectedness)

B. ANICCA (Impermanence):

Everything conditioned is impermanent

“All compounded things are subject to decay”
Nothing lasts forever – bodies, relationships, empires, planets
Moment-to-moment flux
Heraclitus’s “River”: Can’t step in same river twice

Three Levels:

Gross impermanence: Birth-death cycle obvious
Subtle impermanence: Aging process moment-to-moment
Momentary impermanence: Mental/physical phenomena arising-passing each instant

Meditation on Impermanence:

Seeing arising (Uppada), staying (Thiti), passing (Vaya) of phenomena
Develops non-attachment
Prepares for insight into Anatta

UPSC Application:

Acceptance of change
Adaptability in policy-making
Letting go of past glories
Preparing for future challenges

C. DUKKHA (Already covered in First Noble Truth)

Together: Ti-Lakkhana (Three Characteristics) – Anicca, Dukkha, Anatta

Seeing these three in all phenomena = Insight leading to liberation

D. PRATITYASAMUTPADA (Dependent Origination):

“This being, that becomes; from arising of this, that arises”

Nothing exists independently
All phenomena arise dependent on conditions
Mutual causation, not linear
No first cause (rejects Creator God)

12-Link Chain (already listed in Second Noble Truth):

Shows how ignorance leads to suffering through chain of dependent causation
Breaking chain at any link stops suffering

UPSC Significance:

Systems thinking: Everything interconnected
Environmental ethics: Harm to one part affects whole
Social interdependence: Individual-society mutual shaping
Policy implications: Holistic, multi-causal analysis

E. KARMA and REBIRTH:

Karma (Kamma in Pali):

Volitional action (mental, verbal, physical)
Intention most important (accidental acts less karmically weighty)
Creates karmic imprint (Sankara) → future consequences

Three Types:

Kaya-karma: Bodily action
Vaci-karma: Verbal action
Mano-karma: Mental action (thoughts!) – most important

Karmic Results:

Kusala karma (Wholesome): Happiness, good rebirth
Akusala karma (Unwholesome): Suffering, bad rebirth
Abyakata karma (Neutral): No significant result

Rebirth:

Samsara (cycle of rebirth) continues until Nirvana
Six Realms (traditional):
1. Deva (gods) – heavenly, temporary
2. Asura (demi-gods) – jealous, warlike
3. Manusya (humans) – best for enlightenment!
4. Tiryak (animals)
5. Preta (hungry ghosts)
6. Naraka (hell beings)
Rebirth determined by karma
But: No soul transmigrates! (See Anatta)

Buddhist Innovation:

Karma not deterministic (unlike Jainism, Ajivikas)
Present actions matter – can change destiny
Human rebirth precious – only realm where enlightenment possible (gods too comfortable, hell beings too suffering)

UPSC Ethical Implications:

Moral responsibility: Actions have consequences
Hope: Bad present doesn’t determine future (can change through effort)
Equality: All beings have Buddha-nature, can be liberated

C. BUDDHIST COUNCILS (Sanghas)

Councils convened to:

Preserve Buddha’s teachings (originally oral)
Resolve doctrinal disputes
Maintain Sangha discipline (Vinaya)

FIRST BUDDHIST COUNCIL:

Purpose:

Preserve Buddha’s teachings before memory fades
Settle any doubts

Proceedings:

Ananda (Buddha’s attendant) recited Suttas (Discourses)
- “Thus have I heard…” (Evam me sutam)
- Organized by length: Digha Nikaya, Majjhima Nikaya, etc.
Upali recited Vinaya (Monastic discipline)
- Rules for monks/nuns
- Procedures for ordination, confession, expulsion
Both approved by assembly

Result:

Oral tradition established
Tripitaka (Three Baskets) structure formed (written down centuries later)

Controversy:

Some monks (led by Purana) rejected codification: “I prefer to remember as I heard from Buddha directly”
Seeds of later schism

SECOND BUDDHIST COUNCIL:

Date: ~383 BCE (100 years after Parinirvana) Place: Vaishali, Bihar
Convener: Monk Yashas Patron: King Kalashoka (disputed) Participants: 700 monks

Cause: 10 Points Controversy

The Dispute:

Vaishali monks (Vajjiputtakas) adopted 10 “lax” practices:
1. Storing salt in horn (for future use)
2. Eating after midday (monks should eat before noon only)
3. Eating in village then going to another (second meal)
4. Holding separate Uposatha (fortnightly meetings) within same boundary
5. Carrying out acts requiring Sangha approval without full assembly
6. Following practices because teacher did (blind tradition)
7. Eating sour milk after meals
8. Drinking unfermented wine
9. Using mats with fringe
10. Accepting gold and silver (money) – most contentious!

Proceedings:

Debate on whether these practices allowed
Elders (Theras) led by Yashas: Rejected all 10 (strict interpretation of Vinaya)
Vajjiputtakas: Defended practices (lax interpretation)

Decision:

All 10 practices condemned
Orthodox position upheld

Aftermath – FIRST SCHISM:

Vaishali monks refused to accept
Held separate council (Maha Sangiti)
Buddhism split:
1. Sthaviravada (Theravada) – Elders, orthodox, strict
2. Mahasanghika – Great Assembly, liberal, lax
Beginning of sectarian divisions

Significance: Shows tension between rigidity and flexibility, monasticism and lay engagement

THIRD BUDDHIST COUNCIL:

Context:

Ashoka’s patronage → Buddhism immensely popular
Many joined Sangha for material benefits (not spiritual reasons) – quality decline
Heretical views creeping in

Purpose:

Purify Sangha (expel fake monks)
Settle doctrinal disputes
Compile authentic teachings

Proceedings:

Expelled monks with wrong views (Ajivika, materialist ideas)
Confirmed Vibhajjavada (Discriminating Doctrine) as orthodox:
- Middle way between eternalism and nihilism
- Some questions answerable, some not
- Analytical approach
Compiled Abhidhamma Pitaka (Philosophical Psychology)
- Systematic analysis of Buddha’s teachings
- Classification of mental states, processes

Kathavatthu (Points of Controversy):

Moggaliputta Tissa wrote this text
Refuted 250+ heretical views
Established orthodox positions

Missionary Activity:

Ashoka sent missionaries to spread Buddhism:
- Sri Lanka: Mahinda (Ashoka’s son/brother), Sanghamitta (daughter)
- Southeast Asia: Myanmar, Thailand, Cambodia
- Central Asia: Bactria, Gandhara
- West: Egypt, Syria, Greece (limited success)
- East: China (via Silk Road)

Significance:

Buddhism transformed from Indian religion to world religion
Theravada tradition dominant (preserved in Pali Canon)
Ashoka’s rock edicts spread Dhamma

FOURTH BUDDHIST COUNCIL (Controversial – not recognized by all traditions):

Two Versions:

Version 1 (Theravada – in Sri Lanka):

Date: ~29 BCE (1st Century BCE)
Place: Aluvihara, Sri Lanka
Purpose: First written recording of Tripitaka
- Until then, purely oral tradition (500 years!)
- Fear of loss (famine, war)
- Monks wrote on palm leaves in Pali language
Result: Pali Canon (Tipitaka) preserved in writing

Version 2 (Sarvastivada – in Kashmir):

Date: ~100 CE (1st-2nd Century CE)
Place: Kundalavana (Jalandhar or Kashmir)
Convener: Vasumitra, Ashvaghosha
Patron: Kanishka (Kushana Emperor)
Purpose:
- Compile Sarvastivada school’s texts
- Resolve Hinayana-Mahayana debates
- Commentaries on Tripitaka

Proceedings:

Compiled Mahavibhasa (Great Commentary) on Abhidhamma
Written in Sanskrit (not Pali)
Mahayana sutras likely discussed/promoted

Significance:

Sanskrit Buddhist texts begin (alongside Pali)
Mahayana Buddhism gains imperial patronage
Buddhism spreads to Central Asia, China (via Silk Road)
Gandhara and Mathura art schools flourish under Kanishka

SUMMARY TABLE – Buddhist Councils:

Council	Date	Place	Convener	Patron	Key Outcome
First	483 BCE	Rajagriha	Mahakashyapa	Ajatashatru	Oral compilation: Sutta, Vinaya
Second	383 BCE	Vaishali	Yashas	Kalashoka	10 Points condemned; First Schism (Theravada vs. Mahasanghika)
Third	250 BCE	Pataliputra	Moggaliputta Tissa	Ashoka	Purification; Abhidhamma; Missions abroad
Fourth (Theravada)	29 BCE	Sri Lanka (Aluvihara)	–	–	Pali Canon written down
Fourth (Sarvastivada)	100 CE	Kashmir	Vasumitra	Kanishka	Sanskrit texts; Mahayana support

UPSC Importance:

Shows institutionalization of religion
Textual preservation methods (oral → written)
Patronage role (kings like Ashoka, Kanishka)
Schisms and evolution (unity → diversity)
Internationalization (local → global)

D. SANGHA ORGANIZATION

Sangha (Samgha in Pali): Community of Buddhist monks and nuns

Two Aspects:

Arya Sangha: Those who’ve attained enlightenment stages (Stream-winner, Once-returner, Non-returner, Arhat)
Conventional Sangha: All ordained monks (Bhikkhu) and nuns (Bhikkhuni)

Admission:

Open to all – revolutionary!
No caste, gender (initially), class discrimination
Requirements:
- Minimum age (usually 20 for full ordination)
- Free from debts, diseases (some)
- Parental/spousal permission
- Sincere intention

Ordination Ceremony:

Pabbajja (Going forth): Novice ordination (Saman# Buddhism and Heterodox Movements in Ancient India

Go to Home Page

Go to UPSC Govt. Site